4 Ongoing Medicine Lawsuits that Expose the Troubling Saga of the US Healthcare System

By Office
7 Min Read
Medicine Lawsuits
Medicine Lawsuits
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

In the dynamic realm of healthcare, legal battles frequently unfold, shaping the landscape of medical practices, pharmaceutical regulations, and patient rights. The United States, with its complex healthcare system, often finds itself at the epicenter of such litigious proceedings.

From drug recalls to allegations of deceptive marketing, lawsuits play a crucial role in holding entities accountable and safeguarding public health. 

In this article, we look into four ongoing medicine lawsuits in the US, shedding light on their implications and potential ramifications.

Valsartan Contamination Litigation

Valsartan, a commonly prescribed medication for high blood pressure and heart failure, became the subject of litigation. This followed the discovery of impurities in certain batches of the drug. The impurities, including N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA) and N-nitrosodiethylamine (NDEA), are classified as probable human carcinogens and are believed to have resulted from manufacturing processes.

The FDA estimated that 1 in 8,000 individuals on the highest dose of NDMA-contaminated medications for four years might develop cancer.

Consequently, numerous lawsuits were filed against the manufacturers of Valsartan and related medications, alleging negligence in ensuring the safety and purity of their products. The litigation escalated, leading to the consolidation of over 1,400 cases into multi-district litigation (MDL) in a federal court in New Jersey. 

Despite initial scheduling, the first bellwether trial, representing third-party payors seeking compensation, has not yet taken place, as per Forbes.

Suboxone Tooth Decay Allegations

The Suboxone tooth decay lawsuit is a complex legal battle. It stems from allegations that the use of Suboxone, a medication prescribed for opioid addiction treatment, has resulted in significant dental issues for patients. 

These issues include tooth decay, oral infections, cavities, and even tooth loss, leading to substantial physical and financial burdens for affected individuals. 

Plaintiffs argue that Indivior, the manufacturer of Suboxone, did not sufficiently warn healthcare providers and patients about the medication’s potential dental risks. As per TorHoerman Law, they allege that despite knowing these risks, Indivior neglected to provide sufficient warning. 

The lawsuit highlights the broader issue of pharmaceutical companies’ responsibilities in providing accurate and comprehensive information about their products’ potential side effects. 

The consolidation of over 200 lawsuits into multidistrict litigation in the Northern District of Ohio emphasizes the need to hold pharmaceutical companies accountable. It underscores the importance of ensuring transparency in their communications with healthcare professionals and patients.

Elmiron Vision Loss Lawsuits

Elmiron, a medication used to treat interstitial cystitis, has been linked to a rare but serious side effect: vision loss and retinal damage. 

According to Drugwatch, several studies have linked Elmiron, also known as pentosan polysulfate sodium (PPS), to a distinct form of maculopathy. This condition, termed pigmentary maculopathy, is exclusively found in Elmiron users. This condition poses a significant risk of blindness, with no known cure. 

Legal action against Janssen, the manufacturer of Elmiron, began in 2020 as individuals filed lawsuits citing inadequate warning about the medication’s vision-related risks. 

Among the litigants, a notable one is Samantha Padelford, who commenced her lawsuit in 2023. Padelford alleges that she and her physician were not adequately informed about the potential for vision damage. This occurred during her prescription of Elmiron from 2001 to 2008.

Presently, there are 1,829 pending Elmiron cases consolidated in multidistrict litigation in the U.S. District Court of New Jersey.

Zantac Cancer Lawsuits

Zantac, a popular heartburn medication, has been the subject of recent litigation. This follows revelations that it may contain unacceptable levels of a probable human carcinogen, N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA). The presence of NDMA in Zantac is believed to result from the instability of the medication’s active ingredient, ranitidine. Ranitidine can form NDMA when exposed to certain conditions.

This unsettling discovery prompted the FDA to take decisive action in April 2020. The agency instructed all manufacturers to cease the sale of Zantac formulations containing ranitidine in the United States. 

In the aftermath of this regulatory move, federal and state courts were flooded with lawsuits. Plaintiffs ranged from ordinary consumers to military veterans who had relied on Zantac prescriptions from the VA. 

In a recent update, Sanofi, a prominent manufacturer of Zantac, tentatively agreed to settle 4,000 lawsuits related to Zantac’s cancer risk in April 2024. However, the financial terms of the settlement remained undisclosed. Nevertheless, Sanofi still faces around 20,000 lawsuits pending in Delaware state court, as reported by the New York Post.

Moreover, the fate of an even larger pool of cases, numbering around 70,000, hangs in the balance. A judge in Delaware Superior Court deliberates the outcomes, involving not only Sanofi but also other defendants such as GSK, Pfizer, and Boehringer Ingelheim. 


What are the primary allegations in Suboxone lawsuits?

The main allegations in Suboxone lawsuits focus on the medication’s potential to cause severe dental issues such as tooth decay, infections, cavities, and loss. Plaintiffs often assert that the manufacturers failed to adequately warn healthcare providers and patients about these risks.

What is Zantac, and why are there lawsuits related to it?

Zantac is a popular medication used to treat heartburn and acid reflux. Lawsuits have arisen due to concerns that Zantac formulations containing ranitidine may contain elevated levels of the probable carcinogen N-nitrosodimethylamine (NDMA).

What is the primary concern leading to Elmiron vision loss lawsuits?

The primary concern leading to Elmiron lawsuits is the potential association between long-term use of the medication and the development of pigmentary maculopathy. This condition is unique and can result in vision loss or impairment.

Ultimately, these ongoing medicine lawsuits in the US highlight the intricate dynamics between healthcare, regulation, and legal responsibility. 

As these cases progress through the legal system, they hold the potential to shape industry norms and influence public policy decisions. Moreover, they can significantly impact the health landscape for individuals and communities nationwide.

Beyond merely legal battles, they symbolize a broader struggle for transparency, accountability, and the safeguarding of public health interests.

Share this Article